
The Marmara Park Avenue
Best for travelers who want an intimate NoMad base, a Turkish hammam experience, and a seasonal skyline rooftop without the scale of a large Midtown hotel.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Marmara Park Avenue is a polished NoMad five-star hotel with a Turkish hammam, a subterranean saltwater lap pool and a seasonal rooftop bar—best for travelers who want a quieter, boutique-feeling Midtown base. The Peninsula New York is a Beaux-Arts Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with classic Peninsula service, an indoor pool, full spa and multiple bars—best for shoppers and those wanting a central Midtown address and traditional luxury service.
Updated · about 2.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want an intimate NoMad base, a Turkish hammam experience, and a seasonal skyline rooftop without the scale of a large Midtown hotel.

Best for guests seeking a classic Fifth Avenue location, a larger-service luxury hotel with multiple bars, a full-service spa and established Peninsula standards.
When The Marmara Park Avenue wins: choose The Marmara if you prefer a smaller, boutique-feeling luxury hotel in NoMad with an authentic Turkish hammam, a saltwater lap pool and a seasonal rooftop bar that emphasizes skyline views and a quieter neighborhood feel.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula for a central Fifth Avenue address steps from MoMA and Rockefeller Center, a long-standing luxury brand experience with more bars/lounges and a larger-scale spa and guest facilities.
Bottom line: both are five-star Midtown hotels with pools and spas; pick The Marmara for a concentrated wellness focus and NoMad location, or The Peninsula for classic Fifth Avenue luxury and a broader set of on-site services.
| Category | The Marmara Park Avenue | The Peninsula New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique, wellness-forward Midtown hotel in NoMad with historic building scale | Beaux-Arts Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with traditional Peninsula service |
| Location | 114 East 32nd St — NoMad, close to Empire State Building and 33 St subway | 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street — Midtown, steps from 5th Avenue, MoMA and Rockefeller Center |
| Size (guest rooms) | About 126–128 rooms | 219 guestrooms |
| Star & guest rating | 5 stars (hotel marketing) | |
| Pools | Subterranean mosaic-lined saltwater lap pool (7 AM–9 PM; lifeguard on duty) | Indoor pool (1 indoor pool listed; pool hours and rules published by property) |
| Restaurants & bars | Tuti Lounge & Bar (limited service) and seasonal Balcón Rooftop Bar | Clement Restaurant (American), 3 bars/lounges and 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | Marmara Wellness Center with authentic Turkish Hammam, Somadome meditation pod and treatments | Full-service spa with massages, body treatments and facials |
| Known for | Turkish hammam, saltwater lap pool and NoMad setting | Classic Peninsula service, Fifth Avenue address and rooftop appeal |
| Family policy & ages | Welcomes children of all ages; minimum check-in age 21 | |
| Parking & transfers | Valet parking available (fee); airport shuttle not published | Secured valet parking (surcharge); limo/town car service available |
The Marmara Park Avenue sits in NoMad at 114 East 32nd Street, a short walk from the Empire State Building and the 33 St subway.
A good choice if you want a slightly quieter Midtown location with easy subway access and walkable sights.
The Peninsula New York occupies a central Fifth Avenue location at 55th Street, steps from MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
Best for travelers prioritizing a Fifth Avenue address with immediate access to Midtown shopping and cultural sites.
The Marmara offers roughly 126–128 rooms across a historic 21-story building, including several junior and multi-bedroom suites.
Choose The Marmara for suites and select kitchen options in a smaller, renovated historic building.
The Peninsula New York has 219 guestrooms across its Beaux-Arts building with a range of rooms and suites.
The Peninsula gives a broader selection of room categories and a larger inventory for travelers who prioritize service choices over boutique scale.
The Marmara’s on-site dining is compact: Tuti Lounge & Bar for daytime/lounging and Balcón Rooftop Bar seasonally for skyline cocktails.
A small set of thoughtfully appointed outlets—best when you want a quiet lounge and a rooftop drink rather than many dining choices.
The Peninsula lists Clement Restaurant and three bars/lounges, plus 24-hour room service, giving more on-site dining options.
Better if you prefer more on-site dining and lounge options without leaving the hotel.
The Marmara combines a subterranean saltwater lap pool with a Turkish hammam in its Marmara Wellness Center.
If a hammam and a lap-pool are priorities, The Marmara’s wellness setup is the clear draw.
The Peninsula features an indoor pool as part of a full-service spa and health club offering.
The Peninsula is a solid option for guests who want a traditional spa and pool experience paired with larger wellness facilities.
The Marmara’s wellness focus centers on the Turkish Hammam, 24-hour key-card fitness center and a seasonal rooftop bar.
A wellness-first hotel with late-night rooftop drinks in season and round-the-clock gym access.
The Peninsula pairs a full-service spa and 24-hour health club with multiple bars and lobby services.
Stronger for travelers who want a classic hotel nightlife experience and a broad spa program.

Marmara Park Avenue — authentic Turkish hammam, a Somadome meditation pod and a saltwater lap pool.

The Peninsula New York — immediate access to Fifth Avenue, MoMA and Rockefeller Center.

Marmara Park Avenue — roughly 126–128 rooms and a more intimate, NoMad-focused experience.

The Peninsula New York — a larger inventory, multiple bars and a long-established full-service spa.
The Peninsula New York is right on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street. The Marmara is a short walk to parts of Fifth Avenue but is based in NoMad around 32nd Street.
The Marmara Park Avenue has an authentic Turkish Hammam in its Marmara Wellness Center; The Peninsula offers a full-service spa but not a published hammam.
Both hotels list indoor pools. The Marmara’s saltwater lap pool is subterranean and open daily (7 AM–9 PM). The Peninsula lists an indoor pool; check the property for current pool hours and rules.
Both welcome children of all ages and list family-friendly services; The Marmara notes family rooms and children’s menus, while The Peninsula lists family-friendly amenities and multiple bars/lounges.
Neither property is all-inclusive. The Peninsula offers cooked-to-order breakfast for a surcharge; The Marmara offers a to-go breakfast for a surcharge.
Explore how The Marmara Park Avenue stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·